By Alex Ness
On occasion I try to go beyond the concepts of media products or interviews of talents here. I don't say those are bad, but, popular culture includes sports, as in the following commentary, or food culture, and ever changing values and ideas that challenge the mainstream. Challenging the mainstream offers that someday the idea in question might enter our popular ideals, as having been a victor in a free market, free speech, free will society, where the best idea wins the argument. If we do not talk about things, if we erect echo chambers and follow and listen to only those thinkers we already agree with, why talk? Why bother if the possibility of change is impossible? We talk to learn, to negotiate culture, we talk to exchange ideas, ideals, and share dreams and nightmares, because if we do nothing, our society begins to decay, for stasis is not a way to lead, it is the path of those who are accepting of being dead or are too ill to realize that they are dying.
The reason Colin Kapernick began his protest was to bring attention to the problems of police brutality, nationwide inequity towards black people from the US Justice department, and the protest was aimed at changing how people think about the people they watch on the stage of football. These men are not all just muscles and agility and power. They have minds and do not agree with the National Anthem, because the country has failed them.
Recently pro football exile Colin Kaepernick was offered a chance to work out for NFL scouts as arranged by the NFL head office. He saw flaws in the plan, and arranged an alternative event, to showcase his talents. No one signed him. The NFL has suggested either directly or through channels that the overall product offered by the NFL is harmed by his choice to protest the offering of the national anthem. Some cynics suggested that his play had seriously declined, and that taking a knee was a means to making his presence more difficult to remove. Others suggested that his previous career earnings were more than enough to sustain him should his "plot" fail. The worst argument for wanting Kaepernick out of the NFL is to say life is so much better today for African Americans that the act of protest is selfish, false, and attention grabbing. First of all, it is attention grabbing, that was the point to use the attention to draw interest to the cause. Many people were pissed off by it, that too, was the point.
So did his plan work? Did change happen as a result of his protest, and was he able to be redeemed by the changed world and raised aloft to return to the NFL? No. It is also categorically wrong to suggest racism does not still exist, hasn't existed throughout the life of the NFL, and that enough has been done to stop it. He couldn't stop the continuance of such behavior, and his protest didn't change enough minds to do anything. But does that make him wrong? I'd agree that it does seem foolish to see African American athletes raise the specter of being slaves upon the plantation. Millionaires have far more choices than those poor, black or white. That is called hyperbole. It is also false that there is any connection between the protests and improvements in the situations regarding inequity and outright racism. But if John Brown had attacked Harper's Ferry only to die, and not achieve his goals, it doesn't mean he failed. His legend lived on. In Japan there is a cultural concept that sincerity makes any attempt to change or fulfill the task given, already worthy. Rebels do not often succeed. Because they die in the attempt should we say it was wrong to try? If Martin Luther King had not led a movement, would blacks have the vote and power to use it, or would the Jim Crow laws be unchanged still, without his effort, and ultimate sacrifice?
I promise you, I am made uncomfortable by people who think patriotism is foolish, or that love of country is silly. I don't like flag burning. I don't like a number of speakers for the movements of various causes. But I like the fact that those who fought in wars because of the love of country did so knowing that the end result might be someone burning a flag. Many believed in free speech and part of that freedom is the freedom to hear opposing viewpoints and not kill the person speaking those viewpoints. We live in a world where it is FAR easier to walk alongside of people who are not protesting, who are being well paid, and who prefer no one else to rock the boat. Nothing different happens without something, someone or many things changing course. We live in an era where we had Obama, a good man, a President I voted for, who stands to some as a living symbol of the final victory over systemic racism. I say no. He was elected for good reasons, I think I have issues with most presidents so I am not going to jump up and down saying I loved his choices. We are not seeing the end of a revolution. We are seeing a moment in time that defied the traditional ways of thinking. As someone who did analysis for a political non profit organization, I believed in Obama, but believed something that had never happened would have to happen for him to win. And he did.
As a result of his victory we do not thereafter find an African American dominance of politics. Nor do we yet have equality over all for all people in America. You might argue the reasons for that, it isn't going to happen here. My point is, we, as a whole people, Americans, haven't made things that much better nor have they been willing to change. Kaepernick is protesting, or was, the true situation, as well as perhaps being used by some to create a movement that his causing waves might be able to take advantage of that person or group. We have failed to make America the home of righteousness, of hope, of being fed, or being happy. We have allowed some but not all to do that.
And as I go, remember, just because slavery ended, it does not mean inequality ended as well. There have been race riots in this country, and I refuse to believe that because it is comfortable for me, that it is similarly so for others. That isn't the truth.
No comments:
Post a Comment